I had a student inform me towards the end of last semester that she was thinking about continuing on to grad school.
Considering the academic environment in which I work, maybe I should have reacted differently. But I know this young woman.
Grad school -really? Huh?
And admitted that, yes, that was indeed the real reason.
There are plenty of good reasons to get a master’s degree. Your future profession requires one. Hers won’t. You have an intellectual passion for a particular subject matter. She doesn’t. The degree will translate into a real world salary increase. Unlikely.
So for her, I suggested that maybe she didn’t need to get a master’s degree. At least not right away.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for continuing education. Not just in the short term, but, well, forever.
I corresponded for decades with a woman who was a passionate learner. In her 90s and taking a course at NYU, she informed me that any day she learned something new was a good one. What a great philosophy.
My student’s philosophical bent isn’t quite the same.
But she’s not alone.
If you believe Conan O’Brien’s Dartmouth commencement speech statistics (you shouldn’t), 92% of Americans get college degrees. His point, though comically rendered, is that a college diploma today is no big deal.
Higher degrees? Also a lot lower in value than they once were.
But we laid this path out early on. The crowded classes of Advanced Placement courses in high school are a glaring example.
When I was in school, there might have been a dozen kids in AP English, and that from a class of nearly 400. Same for AP Bio and History. The students in those classes were there because it touched on a passion or laid a foundation for specific college study.
Today, they’ll let anyone in.
Maybe not quite, but literally millions of American students are plopping down in desks in AP classes. And most of them don’t belong there.
In a survey conducted a few years ago, AP teachers admitted that most students coming into AP classes were in over their heads. Ninety percent of those teachers said that students were coming into the classes to beef up their high school resumes. And 75% said that there was an institutional push for AP classes to improve academic rankings and reputations.
Great messages we’re sending our kids.
I often wonder what ever happened to average kids? And why we punish students who are stellar artists and scientists and musicians by insisting that they be good everything.
But more I worry about a system that teaches kids how to foster the illusion of success instead of its actuality. At the top of the class are often students who may not always know how to do well but do always know how to look good. They learn what clubs to join, what service to offer, what sports to play –all in an effort to pad their resumes.
The most recent big scandal in our small town revolved around drinking and graduation this year. Big shocker. When the students were called in for discipline, those who fessed up and admitted that yes, they had indeed been drinking, were denied the privilege of walking with their classmates and receiving their diplomas at graduation. The kids who said they hadn’t (wink wink) been drinking got a pass.
Again, nice message. Punish a bit of integrity. Reward a lie.
Politicians still take kickbacks. Academics fudge data to bolster their research. And the Wall Street wizards seem unapologetic for bringing the country to its economic knees.
Our kids should fit right in.